By now, most of America has digested Connecticut's all-time-ugly win over Butler for the national championship in college basketball, and we're waiting excitedly for a draft that may be the last action we see from the National Football League for a while. Many people also have had a chance to watch HBO's Real Sports put the NCAA through the journalism equivalent of a meat grinder. One thing that's clear from the report is that the NCAA isn't getting the job done when it comes to maintaining the integrity and amateurism of college basketball and football.
Of course, things don't have to be this way. To demonstrate that, it's time to take a look at an individual.
America, say hello to Lionel Messi.
Messi is a forward for FC Barcelona, one of the most powerful soccer clubs in Europe, a place that treats soccer more seriously than America treats any single sport. In 2009, Barcelona won the UEFA Champions League Final, Europe's answer to the Super Bowl, and Messi was named FIFA World Player of the Year, in part because he can do things like this with a ball. His current contract will pay him a salary of 10.5 million euros (just under $15 million) a year until 2016.
And he never had to step foot on a college campus.
Messi was so talented so early in his life that he was recruited from his native Argentina to join Barcelona's youth academy in 2000--at the age of 13. One of the things that lured Messi to the academy was the fact that it promised to pay for the drugs he needed to treat a hormone deficiency. (His height is officially listed at 5' 6 1/2".) And there was no NCAA to tell Barcelona that it couldn't offer him this extra benefit. Messi took classes at local schools and trained daily at the academy until he joined Barcelona's senior team in 2004. He has been there ever since.
And, if this report from London's Daily Mail is any indication, he was a relative latecomer to the academy. As Albert Capellas, Barcelona's senior youth coordinator, describes the soccer training, "From the age of seven to the age of 15 everything is about working with the football."
That's right; kids who won't be eligible for Little League for several years are training for a career in soccer. And they don't have to spend a second worrying about their eligibility.
Here in America, we do things differently. Kids can play professional hockey and baseball (and drive a NASCAR racecar) without taking English 101, but the NBA requires you to wait a year after your high school graduation. That means either taking your chances in Europe or playing by the NCAA's rules for at least a year. Likewise, the NFL makes you wait three years, and the NCAA doesn't have to worry about losing quarterbacks to Europe. And as long as people make money off college football and basketball, people are going to cheat at it.
Is the answer to let, say, the Green Bay Packers set up an academy? Maybe not. After all, Barcelona doesn't have a salary cap or a draft, and Americans aren't much better keeping their youth sports under control. ("Play Their Hearts Out," George Dohrmann's book on youth basketball, demonstrates that.) And then there's the fact that a lot of colleges use their football and men's basketball teams to finance the rest of their athletic programs, where trading four years of sweat for a debt-free bachelor's degree is actually a good deal.
But it might be time for us to stop expecting our colleges to serve as minor leagues for our professional sports. Amateurism is a lot easier to accept if you descend from aristocracy, as Baron Pierre de Coubertin did. For many others, turning down LeBron James-level money in exchange for a bachelor's degree may not be that good a deal anymore.
Disagree? Leave a comment at the link at the bottom of this post, and tell me what you think.
No comments:
Post a Comment